A couple of weeks ago, I got invited by the Director of Intellectual Property (IP) of a large international corporation in the energy sector to give a conference on innovation and digitalization. While I am fairly well-versed in both topics, this invitation confronts me with two challenges: (1) Connecting these themes to the intellectual property function, on which I hardly know anything. (2) Drawing the implications of stories we are all starting to become familiar with, such as Netflix, Airbnb, Tesla and Uber, as they apply to B2B industrial players, in a sector characterized by immense capital investments. In the following, “heavy industry” refers to this sector. Is the uberization of heavy industry conceivable? That is the question that I shall examine. I will interview the Chief Digital Officer of this group, as well as two members of his team. All these people are recent nominations, which means they are hard at work analyzing the situation. What follows is my report on what I learned there.
It is eight twenty-two on a November morning. The Sun rises over Rochefort Castle, where both of these two days dedicated to IP are taking place. Close to 150 IP specialists of the group are gathered here. After listening to the highly interesting talks delivered by several important figures, some of whom coming from other industrial companies, it is my turn to get up on the stage.
My talk begins with a couple of examples to sharpen the curiosity of my audience. One of these examples is the acquisition of NEST (see insert), the 200 person startup manufacturing connected thermostats, by Google in 2014 for the sum of 3.2 Billion Dollars. This example is highly significant but not well known in all the circles of heavy industry.
I then discuss the three major trends forcing large organizations to rethink innovation, and that we have described in our book Innovation Intelligence and in our article Towards an Uberization of Intelligence : inflation and fragmentation of knowledge, the acceleration of commoditization, and digitalization. These three trends are causing an acceleration of change that is without precedent, forcing corporations to increase their agility.
The next step is to bring the audience to imagine what the Uber of heavy industry would look like. Such a task is comparatively easy in the case of, say, Vinci, that offers parking spots, and seems to be doing rather well with digitalization. It is is much harder to imagine the uberization of Exploration and Production in the Oil & Gas sector.
Exploration-Production is a B2B business that consists in finding, and then exploiting hydrocarbon deposits. It is a high risk, high return business. We’re talking tens of Billions of Euros in investments. It doesn’t seem possible for a startup to invent an app from a garage that will disintermediate this business. And yet…
And yet, some players are already changing the rules of the game.
A first line of thought and inspiration is provided by what is going on in the aeronautics and astronautics industries. In a nutshell, Boeing is the main historical competitor of Airbus. The new competitors are Space X and Google. Space X puts satellites on orbit at a 30% lower cost than the rest of the industry. Google acquired Titan in 2014, and Titan develops and manufactures… Drones. Tomorrow, as part of its mobility services division, Google could acquire 1000 Airbus planes and bundle a set of services around them. Planes would be demoted to the rank of mere commodities.
The second train of thoughts originates in a project announced by GE in 2014 to be coming online this year, ie in 2016: the Predix platform. Predix is an open platform for applications that can be accessed by any company wishing to develop applications aiming to improve the performance of systems using GE products. What is going on here? The equipment supplier also becomes the supplier of the infrastructure that will enable equipment-based services (predictive maintenance, etc.) Expect shifts in the value chain. This is a good opportunity to draw attention to an excellent book on the topic of platforms: Platform Scale.
Let’s get back to the Oil & Gas sector.
There are in fact at least three ways to imagine the uberization of Oil & Gas.
- Through the suppliers: Suppliers such as GE and Forsys Subsea etc. place more and more sensors in their equipments. Such suppliers are generating, and perhaps analyzing more and more data. They will offer new services based on these data and move up in the value chain.
- Because of the State: While doing research for this conference, I was surprised to find out the following fact: the geoscience data that are essential to the localization and exploitation of deposits, and that are generated thanks to the massive investments of Oil & Gas players, are property not only of these players, but also of States. In a context where open data becomes the norm, it is conceivable that such data will be made available to third parties.
- Through Internet barbarians: as in the above case of aeronautics, there is also a risk coming from big or even perhaps small digital players. IBM, for instance, is currently making its Watson artificial intelligence system to every major company. As is the case with any artificial intelligence system, optimal performance implies a phase of supervised learning. In other words, the engineers and researchers within corporations must contribute part of their know-how to the system to make it relevant. This creates not just a risk of data leakage, but also of know-how leakage. Don’t be evil .
In conclusion, I wish to underscore that the above points are merely lines of thought for the Oil & Gas industry. They could also be applied to other sectors. Three points should be kept in mind in order to develop this analysis:
- Data is gold: the one who controls data wins the war.
- Open is key: it is crucial to think in terms of systems, ecosystems, and platforms (though not necessarily in terms of oil platforms :-))
- Fast & Furious is the rule: we must use the methods of the web barbarians to become as agile as them.
- A. Meige and J. Schmitt, Innovation Intelligence, absans publishing, 2015
- A. Meige and J. Schmitt, Vers une Uberisation de l’intelligence?, Harvard Bus. Rev. France, 2015
- M. Ja., GE créé le premier app store industriel, Les Echos, 2015-11-19
- S.P. Choudary, Platform Scale: How an emerging business model helps startups build large empires with minimum investment, Platform Thinking Labs, 2015
- Google [sic].